This month’s blog post was written by Paul W. Taylor, Partner at Borden Ladner Gervais LLP.
The alter ego trust, once a popular alternative to joint tenancy and discretionary family trusts for the purpose of estate planning to avoid probate tax, may no longer yield such tax savings for all families.
In Ontario, estate administration tax (or probate tax) is imposed at 1.5% of the value (above $50,000) of your estate. This can lead to a hefty tax bill when considering what to do with your assets, such as a family cottage. This blog post will explore the pros and cons of creating an alter ego trust to avoid probate, given the Federal Government’s proposed changes to the capital gains inclusion rate.
As it currently stands, half of all realized capital gains are included in a taxpayer’s income. Pursuant to proposed legislation first announced in the 2024 Federal Budget, the capital gains inclusion rate will increase from one half to two thirds for gains realized on or after June 25, 2024. This is subject, however, to the legislation being passed in Parliament.
Importantly, for individuals and certain trusts, such as gradated rate estates (which includes a deceased taxpayer’s estate for the first 36 months), the inclusion rate is increased to two thirds only for the portion of the gain exceeding $250,000. The first $250,000 is subject to the current one-half inclusion rate. However, for corporations and most trusts (which includes the alter ego trust), the two-thirds inclusion rate will apply to the entirety of the realized capital gain. The difference between a one-half and a two-thirds inclusion rate on the first $250,000 of realized capital gains results in an additional $41,666.67 of taxable income. Assuming the highest combined marginal tax rate of around 53.53% in Ontario, on the first $250,000 of realized capital gains, an individual or an estate would pay $22,304.17 less than a corporation or an alter ego trust on the same gain.
Quick Math for the Skeptics: 0.5353 * (2/3 – ½) * $250,000 = $22,304.17
| On the first $250,000 | Individual | Corporation |
| Inclusion Rate | 1/2 | 2/3 |
| Amount included in Income | 1/2 of $250,000 = $125,000 | 2/3 of $250,000 = $166,666.67 |
| Tax owing | 53.53% of $125,000 = $66,912.50 | 53.53% of $166,666.67 = $89,216.67 |
| Difference | $89,216.67 – $66,912.50 = $22,304.17 | |
An alternative to alter ego trusts in planning to avoid probate tax is to transfer your assets, such as a family cottage, into joint tenancy with your children during your lifetime. A key characteristic of a joint tenancy is the “right of survivorship”. This is what distinguishes it from a tenancy in common. When one joint owner dies, their interest in the property is transferred automatically to the surviving owner(s). As a result, a deceased owner’s interest does not pass through their estate and therefore is not subject to probate tax.
Therefore, it may be possible to trigger the first disposition during the donor’s lifetime, with the one-half inclusion rate applying to the realized gain on the portion of the property that they transfer to their new joint owner(s). The second disposition occurs on the date of the donor’s death, where their remaining interest is automatically transferred to the other joint owner(s). The capital gains on this disposition will be taxed to the donor’s estate, which also qualifies for the $250,000 threshold for the lower inclusion rate.
Keep in mind that while this may seem favourable from a capital gains perspective, joint tenancy comes with many disadvantages that must be considered. For example:
- Taxable disposition during lifetime. There is a taxable disposition during the donor’s lifetime, as opposed to an alter ego trust which allows for a tax-deferred rollover of the property into trust.
- Principal Residence Exemption. If this is a property for which the principal residence exemption applies, there are no capital gains taxes applicable if all conditions of the exemption are met, so triggering it twice is not required (and may not be favourable if the new joint tenant would not qualify for the principal residence exemption).
- Loss of control. As the joint owners acquire identical interests, the donor loses control and exclusive possession rights of the property.
- Exposed to creditor risks. The property is held personally by individuals and is exposed to the risk of creditor and family law claims against a joint owner. Further, consider a cottage that is used by one of the joint owners as a matrimonial home; that owner’s spouse now has statutory protections and rights that cannot be contracted out of.
- Joint tenancy is fragile. The joint tenancy can easily and unilaterally be severed by a single act. When severed, the ownership becomes a tenancy in common and the right of survivorship disappears. This results in the interest in the property of a deceased owner passing through their estate and being subject to probate tax.
The alter ego trust was once a promising option for people 65 years and older looking for estate planning options regarding property (such as a family cottage) that would allow them to maintain control and exclusive possession during their lifetime, avoid capital gains during their lifetime, transfer the property to their children after their death and avoid probate tax. While the alter ego trust still achieves all the above, it now comes with an important asterisk: the increased capital gains inclusion rate.
However, if you only care about reducing the total tax burden with respect to capital gains and probate tax, then the alter ego trust may still be a favourable option where the property is worth more than $1,486,942.67. The reason is that the probate tax on such property would be equal to or greater than $22,304.14, which is the amount of tax that an alter ego trust would pay in excess of an individual on the initial $250,000 of the realized gain. This calculation assumes there are other assets going through probate and so does not consider the $50,000 threshold that is not subject to probate tax.
It is important to note that the proposed increase to the capital gains inclusion rate may have an important impact on your estate planning. Speak to your financial or legal advisors as there is no one-size fits all solution, and it depends on your specific needs and criteria.
DISCLAIMER
Terms of Use
By accessing the Wealth Matters – Our Insights page, you agree that you have read, understood and agree to be bound by the website terms of use, in addition to the terms stated below. If you do not agree with this website’s terms of use, please exit from this page, and do not access any other pages on this website.
Cidel Bank & Trust Inc. (including its subsidiaries and affiliates, “Cidel”) reserves the right, at its discretion, to change, modify, add, or remove portions of this page, and the information contained herein, without prior notice.
Information Is Not Legal or other Advice
Wealth Matters – Ours Insights publications are intended to convey general information about legal issues and developments as of the indicated date. It does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, or any other advice and must not be treated or relied upon as such.
Statements made in Wealth Matters – Our Insights publications, including the interpretation of case law, are of a general nature only and in no way represent a warranty of the position or accuracy of the law at the time, nor do they pre-determine any position Cidel may take with respect to a specific fact situation or particular client matter. Furthermore, Cidel does not endorse, guarantee the accuracy of, or accept any responsibility for any content written or contributed by third parties who are featured as guest bloggers on Wealth Matters – Our Insights, nor does Cidel endorse, guarantee the accuracy of, or accept any responsibility for the content of third-party websites or materials that may be linked, quoted or otherwise referenced in these publications. For greater certainty, Cidel does not warrant or guarantee that the information contained on this page is accurate, complete, updated regularly and obtained from reliable sources.