This month’s blog post was written by Holly Haber, Partner at Fuller Landau LLP.
For U.S. citizens living in Canada, investing in products such as Canadian mutual funds and Canadian exchange-traded funds (ETFs) seems like the natural choice. These products are accessible, familiar, and often recommended by financial institutions and advisors.
But what seems like a simple investment decision can quickly turn into a tax nightmare.
The culprit? A U.S. tax classification called the Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC).
What Is a PFIC?
Under U.S. tax law, a foreign corporation is classified as a PFIC if it meets either of the following tests:
- Income test: At least 75% of its income is passive (e.g., interest, dividends, capital gains); or
- Asset test: At least 50% of its assets produce, or are held to produce, passive income.
Canadian mutual funds and Canadian ETFs primarily hold passive investments. As a result, they almost always fall into PFIC status for U.S. taxpayers.
Why PFICs Are So Problematic
PFIC rules were designed to prevent U.S. taxpayers from deferring tax using offshore investments. In practice, they often result in punitive and highly complex tax outcomes.
Here’s what that means for you:
- Gains are taxed as ordinary income rather than at preferential capital gains rates
- A retroactive interest charge is applied, as if income had been earned evenly over the holding period
- Effective tax rates can be significantly higher than on comparable U.S.-based investments
In short, an investment that is tax-efficient for a Canadian resident can become extremely inefficient for a U.S. citizen.
Limited (and Imperfect) Workarounds
There are elections that can reduce the harshness of PFIC taxation on your U.S. tax return, including:
- Qualified Electing Fund (QEF) election
- Mark-to-market election
Unfortunately, these options are often unavailable or impractical. Many Canadian funds do not provide the information required to make a QEF election. In addition, the QEF election and mark-to-market treatment can still result in unfavorable tax timing and higher taxes. For most investors, these “solutions” don’t fully solve the problem.
The Compliance Burden: IRS Form 8621
Beyond the tax cost, PFICs create a significant compliance burden.
U.S. taxpayers must file Form 8621 annually for each PFIC they own, even if no income is received and no shares are sold. To be clear, a separate Form 8621 must be filed for each individual fund owned. The forms are complex and time-consuming to complete, resulting in a significant increase in professional tax preparation costs. Even more concerning is that failure to file Form 8621 can leave your entire tax return open to IRS review indefinitely, along with potential penalties.
There is a limited exception to the requirement to file Form 8621, when the total PFIC holdings are below $25,000 for individuals or $50,000 for joint filers and no gains or excess distributions occur. That said, the complex tax calculation is still required to be completed.
Why Avoidance Is Usually the Best Strategy
The PFIC rules are notoriously complicated, and even experienced tax professionals find them tedious and challenging to complete. The consequences of getting it wrong can be costly.
For most U.S. citizens living in Canada, the combination of the punitive tax treatment, ongoing reporting requirements, and high compliance costs, makes Canadian mutual funds and ETFs a poor fit.
Final Thoughts
Canadian mutual funds and ETFs may be staples of Canadian investing, but for U.S. citizens, they can create outsized tax headaches.
Before investing, it’s critical to understand how the PFIC rules apply to your situation. In many cases, avoiding PFICs altogether, by focusing on U.S.-domiciled mutual funds and ETFs, or other tax-efficient structures, can lead to simpler compliance and better long-term results. It is also worth noting that the PFIC rules generally do not apply to investments held within a Canadian Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP).
When it comes to cross-border investing, what works locally doesn’t always work globally.
DISCLAIMER
Terms of Use
By accessing the Wealth Matters – Our Insights page, you agree that you have read, understood and agree to be bound by the website terms of use, in addition to the terms stated below. If you do not agree with this website’s terms of use, please exit from this page, and do not access any other pages on this website.
Cidel Bank & Trust Inc. (including its subsidiaries and affiliates, “Cidel”) reserves the right, at its discretion, to change, modify, add, or remove portions of this page, and the information contained herein, without prior notice.
Information Is Not Legal or other Advice
Wealth Matters – Ours Insights publications are intended to convey general information about legal issues and developments as of the indicated date. It does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, or any other advice and must not be treated or relied upon as such.
Statements made in Wealth Matters – Our Insights publications, including the interpretation of case law, are of a general nature only and in no way represent a warranty of the position or accuracy of the law at the time, nor do they pre-determine any position Cidel may take with respect to a specific fact situation or particular client matter. Furthermore, Cidel does not endorse, guarantee the accuracy of, or accept any responsibility for any content written or contributed by third parties who are featured as guest bloggers on Wealth Matters – Our Insights, nor does Cidel endorse, guarantee the accuracy of, or accept any responsibility for the content of third-party websites or materials that may be linked, quoted or otherwise referenced in these publications. For greater certainty, Cidel does not warrant or guarantee that the information contained on this page is accurate, complete, updated regularly and obtained from reliable sources.
In making the Wealth Matters – Our Insights page available, no client, advisory, fiduciary or professional relationship, including a client-solicitor relationship is created, intended or established. The contents are not a substitute for the user seeking advice from a professional that is familiar with the reader’s factual situation or circumstances.